Do you like the Holliday deal?

While we wait for Joe Stiglich to bring us the latest update on how soon the A’s and Rockies will¬†finalize the Matt Holliday trade, we’re wondering how fans of the green & gold feel about the impending deal. If you’ve got a second, cast your vote here .


Jon Becker

  • Big J

    Neither yes or no is really the appropriate answer – for what we know, I say no. If there’s an extension involved, a reasonable one that is, I say yes.

  • Marc

    Depends on how long we retain Holliday’s services. If we are renting him for a few months to get more prospects then I don’t think the deal is such a great thing. If we sign him for a few years and build an offense around him, then I think it is a good deal and we should take the chance.

    Early poster mentioned a lineup with Giambi and Cust. I just don’t see it. I think their both DHs and not 1Bs.