Time is short for BEST, Robeson and Peralta Creek

Tonight, State Administrator Vincent Matthews decided to phase out two small high schools: the Business Entrepreneurial School of Technology (BEST), one of two schools on the West Oakland McClymonds campus, by 2011, and the Paul Robeson School of Visual & Performing Arts, one of four schools on East Oakland’s Fremont campus, by 2012.

Peralta Creek Middle School, which is in the second year of a phase-out (even if people at the school didn’t learn that, definitively, until more recently), closes at the end of the school year.

An emotional, historical discussion unfolded as retiring board member Greg Hodge, teachers and others traced the roots of these struggling schools to their much-celebrated origins not long ago.

Hodge said these schools and other small, themed start-ups were promised things that weren’t delivered (or which have since been taken away). A kitchen for the culinary arts program at BEST, for example, or wireless access for a technology school — or a performing arts program for a performing arts school.

David Kakishiba, the board president, agreed. But, he said, he doubted — even at the time that many of the schools opened — that those promises would be fulfilled. He said the board repeatedly asked to see business plans that would illuminate how these educational innovations would be carried out, to no avail.

“What we got was a parade of celebration,” Kakishiba said. He added, “I don’t think all of these schools were designed, planned, or resourced with the level of seriousness needed to fulfill that promise.”

Any new school faces its share of challenges. On top of those, Oakland’s start-ups (particularly those located in areas with declining populations of school-age children, such as West Oakland) have contended with new district policies designed to instill competition by creating more choices for families. New charter and district schools, along with OUSD’s School Options Program, encouraged families to vote with their feet.

(On the flip side, many `hills schools’ grew overcrowded as a result of these policies — another issue on tonight’s agenda that drew some impassioned speech.)

Then, when less popular OUSD schools — new and old — saw their student populations take a nose dive, they faced the consequences of another policy, one that allots funds to each school based loosely on its enrollment.

I wasn’t here when all of these schools opened, but I wonder: Did Darwinism come up in board or staff discussions? Was it anticipated, from the start, that — given the steep enrollment declines in parts of the district, beginning in 2002 — some of these schools would clearly fail without huge subsidies?

Katy Murphy

Education reporter for the Oakland Tribune. Contact me at kmurphy@bayareanewsgroup.com.

  • http://www.bumblenet.net Patrick Simon

    Encroachment on the general fund budget because of declining enrollment is a very serious issue for a already struggling school district. Programs such as BEST are badly needed in West Oakland and it could have served the community well in the long term. I know I lived on Adeline Street for 5 years and I do miss my neighborhood! In today’s failing state budget crisis local and district staff should have seen these issues at BEST years ago and started the grant/local business/public private partnership program and even fund raising could have helped. There are pockets of dollars for programs like these but it looks like there may have been lack of clear understanding of in business we have to get to a ROI based on NVP. Business Technology schools need solid business plans and we can not teach what we do not understand. As far as the wireless piece goes, that was the easiest part I know at least 2-3 vendors who would have loved to give this to Best just for the sake of giving! I hope we can save the program or make plans to bring it back with conditions. Our students need every chance in business/technology they can get! Katy now you know I can get honey out of rocks!

  • http://www.bumblenet.net Patrick Simon

    Katy i read your blog often I am so glad you still do education. You are wonderful and Oakland is lucky to have you! I live in Texas now….

    Patrick Simon

  • Pingback: Deja Vu: When the same school closes twice - The Education Report - Katy Murphy covers what’s going on in the Oakland schools()

  • Pingback: Jennifer Ward: Disappearing Behind Them: Phasing Out Failing Small Schools | A Better Oakland()