Let me get this straight:
Aragon, Carlmont and Woodside all lost on the same day?!?!
We’ve known that girls soccer in the Peninsula Athletic League’s Bay Division has been extremely competitive, but I challenge you to find one person who believed that would’ve happened at any point in the season.
Adding to the huh? nature of Tuesday, Carlmont and Woodside qualified for the Central Coast Section playoffs despite losing. And Menlo-Atherton, which began the day in eighth place, not only won, but gave no fewer than three other programs a huge assist by doing so.
Talk about confusing.
Mostly, it comes down to M-A handing Aragon a 3-0 loss.
“You are kidding me,” Woodside coach Jose Navarrete said when told of Aragon’s defeat. “Unreal. Whoa. Shock. Shock. Shock.”
Aragon began the day in fourth place at 23 points, one point in front of Menlo. Woodside and Carlmont both had 29, tied for second behind Bay-champion Burlingame. With two games remaining (entering Tuesday), Aragon was still (barely) in the race to finish in the top-three, a result that would earn an automatic CCS berth.
But thanks to M-A’s upset over the Dons, both Woodside (a 1-0 loser to Menlo) and Carlmont (which fell 2-0 at Burlingame) retained their six-point leads over Aragon. With its win, Menlo vaulted Aragon and sits in fourth with 25 points, but the Knights could pull no closer than one point behind the second-place teams by winning their finale. So … Woodside and Carlmont clinched playoff berths.
(If Woodside and Carlmont finish in a tie, Woodside earns the Bay’s second seed for CCS seeding purposes thanks to its 1-0-1 record vs. the Scots. And both teams appear headed to the Division I bracket, but that’s a whole separate story.)
So M-A helped Woodside and Carlmont secure their CCS berths. But the team that benefited the most from M-A’s big day was Menlo.
Both Aragon and Menlo were already looking at the at-large route for playoff qualification. But the CCS bylaw that prevents leapfrogging a team in the same league could damage Menlo’s chances should the Knights have enough power points to otherwise qualify but finish behind Aragon.
True, Menlo’s two-point lead over the Dons seems somewhat fluid when considering the Knights finish at Burlingame while Aragon wraps up with San Mateo. But Menlo has positioned itself to control its own fate, at least as far as fourth place is concerned.
“Which is great,” Knights coach Donoson Fitzgerald said. “We want to get in fourth. Wow, I’m shocked (about M-A beating Aragon). Shocked but happy.”
As for Tuesday’s result that had the Bay buzzing …
M-A jumped to lead in the first five minutes when Ashley Parrish punched in a pass from Vanessa Renkel. But then Aragon took over in the middle of the first half and threatened to pull even.
M-A coach Jenna Carson said the high pressure the Dons were inflicting was exactly the type of scenario that had been her side’s downfall on many occasions. The difference on Tuesday? “It started with the goalie,” Carson said.
Bears junior net-minder Brooke Weisenfluh came up with the clutch stops to protect her team’s slim lead, and then M-A’s offense responded by adding to the advantage. With Renkel, a sophomore forward, assisting again, freshman Gillian Collum notched a transition goal that put M-A up, 2-0. And then Renkel completed her impressive haul by scoring the third goal down the stretch.
“We play Aragon hard for whatever reason,” said Carson, whose team tied the Dons 1-1 earlier in the season. “The girls feel they should beat Aragon no matter where Aragon is in the standings. … (It was) definitely nice for our program.”
Despite his surprise at the final score in the M-A vs. Aragon game, Woodside’s Navarrete said he knew all too what M-A could do. Woodside beat the Bears 3-1 in the Bay’s second round, but Navarrete and Carson both said the score was deceptive and that M-A had the upper hand except for the Wildcats’ scoring binge (three goals in 10 minutes).
“Ninety-five percent M-A,” Navarrete said. “That was the biggest whupping we got. They just toyed with us. … They were way more athletic than we were.”
As for Aragon, coach Michael Flynn had no answers when asked how his team suffered a second straight 3-0 loss.
“I don’t know. I really don’t,” he said minutes after the game. “We’re done. I don’t even think I’m going to take my team to CCS.”
Less than two weeks ago, the Dons were flying high after a 2-1 win over Carlmont. But three lows in a row have proved trying, especially for a team that had only lost once all season before that.
The guess here? A win over San Mateo makes the Dons very competitive for an at-large berth. And if the Dons can put the brakes on their skid …
Aragon has beaten Woodside and Carlmont, and owns a tie against Burlingame. Talk about the type of team nobody would want to face come CCS.
Two quotes from elsewhere in the Bay:
San Mateo coach Victor Montoya, after his team recorded its sixth tie of the Bay season, a scoreless draw at Terra Nova: “I’m setting the record here.”
Burlingame coach Phillip De Rosa, on his players bearing down on an unbeaten Bay season after already clinching the championship: “They’re not satisfied. That’s the key.”