Part of the Bay Area News Group

Rocky road for another 9th Circuit nominee?

By Josh Richman
Friday, March 26th, 2010 at 11:01 am in Obama presidency.

Just as things start heating up for Goodwin Liu, the Cal law professor whom President Barack Obama nominated last month to the San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, the President has named another nominee to that same appellate bench: U.S. District Judge Mary Murguia of Arizona.

Mary MurguiaIf confirmed, Murguia, 49, would have a lifetime appointment to a seat vacant since Feb. 12, when Circuit Judge Michael Daly Hawkins of Arizona took senior status. Nominated to the federal trial court by President Bill Clinton, she is the first Latina to serve on the federal bench in Arizona.

Earlier, she was counsel, principal deputy director and then director of the Executive Office for U.S. Attorneys at the U.S. Department of Justice in Washington, D.C. from 1998 to 2000; a prosecutor in the Arizona U.S. Attorney’s office from 1990 to 1998, the latter half of which she spent as chief criminal deputy; and a prosecutor in the Wyandotte County District Attorney’s office in Kansas City, Kan. (of which she’s a native) from 1985 to 1990. She holds two bachelors degrees and a law degree from the University of Kansas. (Boo, jayhawks.)

The dockets are Arizona’s federal courts are heavy with illegal-immigration and drug-related cases, so that’s some of the expertise Murguia is presumed to bring. Her confirmation probably won’t be smooth sailing: her twin sister is Janet Murguia, president and CEO of the National Council of La Raza, a Hispanic civil rights and advocacy group that many conservatives see as a far-left outfit. In fact, she recused herself last year from handling a racial profiling case against Maricopa County Sheriff Joseph Arpaio, whom the NCLR has blasted repeatedly for his immigration enforcement methods.

Federal circuit judges are paid an annual salary of $184,500. The 9th Circuit court is the nation’s largest, serving nine western states and two Pacific Island jurisdictions, and reported 12,223 appeals filed in 2009.

[You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.]

  • Mike F.

    She’s got the work experience to back up her appointment, which cannot be said for Mr. Goodwin Liu. Bonus points for recusing herself for the implied conflict with the sister. Rocky Road? Everyone should be held to some scrutiny before getting the post, so “rocky” is just part of the path to getting there. She should make it, but Mr. Liu is the person who does not belong on any high court. Message to Mr. Liu – get out of academia and actually do some work in the court system. Also, learn the concept of “billability” and how competiton is good for this country.

  • John W.

    Josh, I take it you are a K-Stater. Am I right? You can admit it. You are not alone out here. How about that Xavier game?

    As for the nomination — sounds like a total whacko to me. By all means, let’s judge her qualifications based on what her sister does. We’ve already got one Latina woman on the SCOTUS. We don’t need to get carried away. If we dig far enough, we might even find out her great, great grandmother came here illegally. Can she provide proof that that did not happen. After all, if she gets on the Appeals bench, that’s only one dangerous step away from the big court. And she went to the liberal law school in Kansas (by Kansas standards), not to a nice conservative school like Washburn. She probably got all that prosecutorial and U.S. Attorney experience based on affirmative action. Definitely, GOP must stonewall this nomination. They don’t need to oppose her. Just put one of those anonymous holds on all Senate action, just like they taught us it should be done in high school civics.

  • Josh Richman

    John W., I’m a Missouri Tiger and proud of it.

  • John W.

    Okay, that makes sense, in terms of the animus toward KU. Great J-school too.