Part of the Bay Area News Group

Newark saw fire disability retirement rates double over 20 years

By Matt Artz
Thursday, August 11th, 2011 at 2:42 pm in Uncategorized.

After getting pension info from Alameda County cities last month, I asked them for a lot more info recently.

Newark, bless their hearts, responded quickly and thoroughly.

The most interesting item from Yowzah town involves firefighters retiring on disability:

Between 1990 and 2000, only 16.67 percent of Newark firefighters retired on a disability pension

Between 2005 and 2010, that number jumped to 38.46 percent.  Newark no longer has a fire department.

For cops, the frequency of disability retirements rose from 37.5 percent in the 90s to 53.85 percent over the past six years.

Why the big jump?

Newark has some theories. Click where it says to click to read them.

      The job is no more dangerous for Firefighters then it was 20 years ago.  In fact, safety equipment is much better and procedures have been refined to make the job safer.  For police officers, the job is probably more dangerous given the proliferation of weapons, the larger number of parolees, and the willingness for the “bad guys” to use weapons.  Respect for police officers’ authority has also declined.

Documentation of injuries during firefighters and police officers careers is much more comprehensive.  There has been a change in employee mindset to document every injury regardless of severity where in the past some would not have been reported

State legislation has been adopted that makes many types of illnesses “presumptive”.  This means that if a police officer or firefighter contracts certain diseases/illnesses they are “presumed” to be job related.  Such things as heart disease, certain types of cancers, etc… 

When someone retires on a disability retirement, a significant percentage of the retirement pay is tax free. I believe this was an unintended result of some legislative action taken years ago.

 It is much easier to get a disability retirement now then it was 20 years ago.

[You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.]

  • Marty

    What a racket.

    Drive over a pothole, lose a your child’s teacher?

    Blame the fairy tale of 20% YOY increases in property values, then blame firefighters.

  • west

    The whole Firemen and Police Officers Pensions is just the half of it, a very large percentages are sucking the disability tit. I would like to see a investigation on there disability abuse, not all but a healthy percentage.
    While we are discussing it, many Municipalities are facing bankruptcy. That nullifies present labor contracts and there pension system.
    Lets be fair and let them have the private Industry average for pensions.