“Selfish” may have been the key word in a discussion Wednesday on the Ohlone College board’s unique election system, which seems to favor incumbents through the use of numbered seats.
Ironically, the arrangement was put in place 28 years ago to oust a controversial trustee but then backfired against the board member who proposed it.
Sound confusing? That’s why the League of Women Voters of Fremont, Newark and Union City asked the board to return to a top-vote-getter system of the kind Americans are more familiar with.
The majority of trustees, though, said they prefer to maintain a non-competitive atmosphere through numbered seating, which guarantees that no incumbents ever face off against each other.
They can only be individually challenged by non-board members, which has resulted in some incumbents facing several candidates and others facing none.
“I think it’s a very selfish perspective as an incumbent,” said Trustee Richard Watters, noting that he got nearly three-quarters of the vote when he ran for a seat. “Who’s going to run against that?
“It’s not fair. It’s intimidating to have to pick someone out to run against. It’s very confrontational.”
On the other hand, interim Trustee Trisha Tahmasbi said she believes numbered seats mean greater responsibility among board members who will have to answer for their actions.
“I’m anticipating a tough campaign in November,” she said, noting that she expects several challengers to target her for removal. “You can take take me on head to head. There’s more of an accountability level.”
Trustee Nick Nardolillo threw down a gauntlet in his support of numbered seats, saying: “You can focus on an individual you think is not doing a very good job. If you’re too chicken to take on somebody … I don’t think you’re going to have what it takes to serve on the board.”
Board President Garrett Yee disagreed with the system, which has allowed him to run unchallenged as a trustee.
“We’ve all been talking about how we feel,” he said, as opposed to how Tri-City area voters feel. “It’s very frustrating that your top two candidates (can) align with one seat. It gives less choice.”
In the end, Trusteee John Weed agreed with Watters and Yee, but Trustees Bob Brunton and Bill McMillin sided with Nardolillo and Tahmasbi, so the board decided to keep the current system.
Originally, Weed explained that Trustee Ray Snow suggested numbered seats 28 years ago. That allowed voters to target controversial board member Marilyn Blawie for removal, but then Snow himself was ousted by Dan Archer.